Asus Crosshair IV Extreme

The Heatsink

 

The Heatsink

The Crosshair IV Extreme's heatsink follows on from the previously reviewed Formula motherboard.

Asus Crosshair IV Extreme     Asus Crosshair IV Extreme

All major integrated components are cooled by this single heatsink module. A single heatpipe connects two cooling arrays; the Northbridge and VRMs are kept at bay by the chunkier unit, while the Southbridge and Lucid chip sit under a metal plate. Naturally the heatpipe spans the whole length of the cooler.

There is a little more to the heatsink however. Those with a keen eye will have noticed two wires coming out of the VRM + NB cooling side of the heatsink. "OH NO", you might have exclaimed. Sadly we can only confirm your fears in that it is indeed actively cooled. Nope, it's not passive - there's a little fan sitting above the Northbridge! Thankfully the second cable isn't for another fan, but rather to power the LED that pulsates underneath the Republic of Gamers logo. But seriously, whether it has one or two fans, it's still bad news.

Let me tell you readers a short story - if you know me and my boring tales, then kindly skip paragraph.

Back in 2004, when AMD's Athlon 64 range and nVidia's nForce 4 MCPs were the king of platforms, Asus' motherboards were well known for one thing - Noise.

I remember the first time I ever came across the Asus A8N SLI Deluxe motherboard. It was great. It would let you combine two GeForce 6800 Ultra's in SLI, overclock Athlon 64 3000's to the dizzy heights of 2.70GHz and onwards and even had SATA II. This was all brilliant, except for one thing. Asus saw fit to cool their nForce 4 SLI chipset with a basic aluminium cooler and then drop a 40mm fan on top that would spin in excess of 7000RPM. It didn't push an awful lot of air but seriously, you could hear it from another room! Asus finally put an end to this with the release of the A8N SLI Premium, which sported a passive heatpipe design. From here on, the saga of active motherboard coolers were over...until now.

Needless to say, we installed the Crosshair IV Extreme with high hopes that the fan would rarely switch itself on...Oh how wrong we were. By default, the fan spins at its maximum speed and believe me it can be heard over the loudest of Multi GPU configurations. The motor noise is high pitched and much like the dreaded A8N Ultra/SLI series coolers, it can be heard from adjacent rooms.

Having now spoken to Asus, we were made aware of the fact that the 40mm fan was a space saving measure that replaces the optional "bolt on" fan that previous ROG packages included. Apparently the fan is only of use under conditions of low case airflow, such as watercooled CPU/GPU.

Our opinion still stands however. A 40mm fan can only move so much air during a given rotation and so it comes to no surprise that it has to spin very quickly. We would guess that the fan pushes no more than 20CFM. Even if the board's components are under stress due to low airflow, there is only so much this fan can do to ease temperatures. The endgame is that anyone that is serious about overclocking would ensure that there is sufficient airflow inside their chassis or on their test bench in the first place. Even a set of low speed 120mm fans in the vicinity of the motherboard would suffice in our opinion.

There is simply no way of sugar coating this. Asus are right; the heatsink is capable of cooling the Crosshair IV Extreme passively under most, if not all scenarios. Simply unplug it and the board will operate normally and in silence. On the basis of this, we continue to wonder why the fan was necessary in the first place but dwelling on this is futile.

We're almost out of pictures but fear not, the review will stay interesting for a while longer.

«Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Next»

Most Recent Comments

29-09-2010, 19:28:31

wraithien
Good review as usual though it did seem a little short. I had a bad feeling regarding the actively cooled heatsink when i first looked at the board a few weeks back, out of interest how hot does it get when the fan is unplugged? Hydra performance is thankfully better than i expected too. At £250 its not cheap especially with AMD's new none compatible CPU's coming quite soon. Never the less I will give this board some serious consideration for my new build.Quote

29-09-2010, 19:34:47

AMDFTW
Quote:
Originally Posted by tinytomlogan View Post

At last, it's finally here. After four weeks of examining Asus' flagship AMD motherboard, what do we think of it?

Continue Reading
there is no graph for metro fella

man i realy wished this performed better its a shame thoQuote

29-09-2010, 20:08:41

alienware
I must admit that I'm not a fan of the ROG motherboards. I liked the CHIV but this one goes too far with add on crap that's all a bit pointless.

I mean sure, if you are a gadget freak then it may appeal to you, but the bottom line on a board of this cost is function. Function should come over form as it does with the MSI.

Yet it wasn't even able to match the MSI's bottom line function.

So all of the stick on tat does very little if it is being compared to what I would call a budget board.

It was the same with my CHII ROG. Loads of stupid tat (The LED poster for one) that was fun for about five minutes and then got old fast. The only thing I really liked on that board that explained away the premium price was the cmos reset on the IO shield - that was bloody marvellous. But the rest? I ended up disconnecting the LED poster after about six boots never to use it again.

And then I got my M3A32 deluxe wifi which was also a very expensive board, yet doesn't have any silly bits on and has far more to offer in the way of function.

Again I suppose Asus are going to cater to many people with this board, but what with this, the Ares, the Mars II (if it ever comes along) and that add in board previewed today I just worry sometimes that they are being a bit over indulgent and started to fritter away their successes on stupid stuff.

It's all starting to seem a little... How do you say it?... EVGA.

Sorry if I sound harsh or pessimistic, I am only thinking aloud. But I think this time MSI have shown that stuff like this and EVGA boards are all rather pointless.

Thanks ever so much as ever for the reviews guys. Quote

30-09-2010, 01:11:52

Wendriel
hi, i wanted to know if any of you readers, or even tom could tell me if this mobo is able to boot from a PCI e slot. im looking to build a system and have been hoping this board comes out, but was set on getting the formula. the only thing holding me back was the fact that it couldnt boot from pcie. i was planning on an OCZ RevoDrive (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820227597) but on the OCZ site, it states, "-Asus Crosshair IV – Please check with motherboard manufacturer for BIOS update to enable boot over PCIe." basically, with the new board, has the bios been updated to allow pci e booting? or am i still SOL...Quote

30-09-2010, 03:52:20

tinytomlogan
PCIE booting is not something we test for so Im affraid you will have to look on the Asus website for specifics dude sorry Quote
Reply
x

Register for the OC3D Newsletter

Subscribing to the OC3D newsletter will keep you up-to-date on the latest technology reviews, competitions and goings-on at Overclock3D. We won't share your email address with ANYONE, and we will only email you with updates on site news, reviews, and competitions and you can unsubscribe easily at any time.

Simply enter your name and email address into the box below and be sure to click on the links in the confirmation emails that will arrive in your e-mail shortly after to complete the registration.

If you run into any problems, just drop us a message on the forums.