Silicon Power E10 and M10 SSDs

Test Setup & Synthetics

Test Setup

Todays test setup is our standard P55 based test hardware, and as we still had the ASUS Maximus III Extreme in the OC3D bunker from last weeks testing it was decided to use that to make sure we provided the best possible scaffolding for this house to be built on.

Motherboard : ASUS Maximus III Extreme
CPU :               Intel Core i7 870
Graphics :        ASUS GTX275
Cooler :           Cooler Master Hyper 212 Plus with Arctic Cooling MX3 Thermal Compound
PSU :               Cougar 1000CM
OS :                 Windows 7 64
RAM :               G.Skill ECO PC3-12800 CL7

Synthetic Benchmarks

Testing SSD drives is always a strange experience. Most of the standalone programs designed to test drive speeds are better suited to testing mechanical devices and it's for this reason that we always over-test something to ensure we get a good feel for the speeds available.

As always all our tests are run five times with the highest and lowest being removed and an average taken of the rest.

ATTO Disk Benchmark
Read Test

The ATTO benchmark is a good test of a drives sustained transfer rates both in read and write conditions. It is able to test in both small and large blocks, which is especially good with SSDs as they definitely perform better with large file chunks. Although that isn't to suggest they aren't good with small ones, just the difference is better on the larger items.

Both drives provided exceptional read speeds. Any worries that the inability to get a good look at either the controller or cache chips might mean something being hidden were quickly dispelled. The E10 surpassed the magic 200MB/s barrier on all of our tests. The Samsung based M10 provided phenomenal consistency with 150MB/s seen in everything but the 8192 test.

Write Test

Read speeds, like clock speeds, tend to be the big number than gets heavily advertised and doesn't tell the full story. After all, a drive that you don't write to is almost entirely pointless, and one that only writes very slowly is almost equally without use. Thankfully both drives keep up the read performance.

The E10 consistently around 150MB/s, only dropping below 100MB/s in the small 128 test. 

The M10 once again shows the consistency achieved by using the popular Samsung NAND MLC, with around 95MB/s seen across all the tests. 

Crystal Disk Mark 2.2

Read Test

Crystal Disk Mark is able to test tiny, medium and sequential reading and writing with a variety of sizes. To ensure compatibility we use the default settings. The read tests are indicative of the performance difference between the two drives, with the Sequential test backing up the ATTO results, and the 4K and 512K random tests providing a sterner test. Naturally the 4K result shows the poor performance of SSDs with exceptionally small files, but once we reach a more realistic size the speed differential between solid state and mechanical is there for all to see.

Write Test

The results for the write test are very similar to the read test. Small sizes are bad, but otherwise the transfer rate is around the ATTO results and also around the manufacturers specifications.

PC Mark Vantage

PC Mark Vantage uses a variety of in-built applications and testing situations to provide a more real-world scenario and a greater approximation of the speeds that should be achieved when the entire system is in use.

Rather than run the entire Vantage suite of tests we've concentrated on the HDD Suite. The faster E10 giving a result 1000 points higher than the M10, but neither are slouches. 


Viewing the breakdown of the results obtained we can see how the entire subsystem can slow down the transfer rates. Of course these are still vastly above what you'd expect with a mechanical drive, but we can't help to be slightly disappointed by some of the scores when the system is really working hard. Especially strange is how the M10 was faster at application loading and Windows Media Player than the E10.

Does this translate into extra speed loading games?

«Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next»

Most Recent Comments

26-02-2010, 08:11:35

tinytomlogan
VonBlade quinches his thirst for reviewing hardware, this time by taking a look at some Silicon Power SSD's.



Continue Reading

08-03-2010, 18:10:16

bhaberle
I wonder how bad the degradation will be.

08-03-2010, 18:17:07

VonBlade
As they come complete with the firmware necessary to reduce wear, then no worse than any other SSD.

Although the name is not as well known, the important parts are Samsung and Intel. Nuff said.

08-03-2010, 18:29:37

bhaberle
Yeah. You can't go wrong with Samsung. They are known to do the best against degradation.

09-03-2010, 14:24:33

VonBlade
Then if you read the review you gain this information before hand. So you don't ask already answered questions

09-03-2010, 18:50:50

bhaberle
I was referring to firmware of the hard drive, not the physical parts. No need respond though. Thanks.

01-04-2010, 03:08:54

ULPResearch
Nothing about power usage of these SSD drives. Silicon Power is also silent about that on their web site. Low power usage means nothing if there is no specification. E.g. I have seen Kingston 2.5 inch SSD drives which could consume above 5Watt! You can find 5400rpm drives nowadays consuming less than 2 Watt and much less in idle state. This is significant issue for net- and notebooks.

08-12-2012, 15:02:17

Deadfire19
Are these better than todays SSDs?

08-12-2012, 17:49:24

yassarikhan786
Quote:
Originally Posted by Deadfire19 View Post
Are these better than todays SSDs?
Are you a troll reviving old threads or just some spam bot? If it's the latter I won't be expecting a reply
Reply
x

Register for the OC3D Newsletter

Subscribing to the OC3D newsletter will keep you up-to-date on the latest technology reviews, competitions and goings-on at Overclock3D. We won't share your email address with ANYONE, and we will only email you with updates on site news, reviews, and competitions and you can unsubscribe easily at any time.

Simply enter your name and email address into the box below and be sure to click on the links in the confirmation emails that will arrive in your e-mail shortly after to complete the registration.

If you run into any problems, just drop us a message on the forums.