Intel Core i5-2405S Review
Published: 31st August 2011 | Source: Intel | Price: |
The Intel Core i5-2405S is probably best described as a schizophrenic CPU.
Normally CPUs fall into two categories. There are those that exist solely to power the mighty gaming rigs of the enthusiast market, and those that happily bumble along in a business environment. The i5-2405S is somehow both and neither.
When compared to other Intel CPUs on the LGA1155 socket the major benefit that this has over a Core i5-2500K or similarly non-HT processor is the low TDP. Rather than sup upon 95W, the i5-2405S has a ceiling of 65W. This is obviously a boon if you happen to run a fleet of office PCs and want the lowest electricity bill/carbon footprint possible. But then in a pure 'letter writing' way almost anything will handle such a task. If you require it to do more than that, almost anything that requires a decent amount of CPU power, then the low clock-speed is a serious detriment to a smooth and efficient workflow. There is no point in saving a tiny bit of power and heat if it takes twice as long to complete each task.
So maybe it works as a gaming CPU. After all we saw in both 3D Mark tests and Crysis that, with a decent GPU, the Core i5-2405S is plentifully powerful enough to give you a decent gaming experience. Again things aren't quite as clear cut as that.
Firstly neither 3D Mark Vantage nor Crysis Warhead with zero anti-aliasing will put much strain upon your system and, as we saw in 3D Mark 11, once the detail level and so CPU Workload increases, so the 2405S starts to struggle.
Secondly, and of more obvious importance, is the price point of the Core i5-2405S. Although pricing varies a bit around the internet the Core i5-2405S is generally to be found for the same price as the Core i5-2500K. The i5-2500K is an absolute demon of a CPU. It will run at low speed, low energy if that's what you require but it will equally blaze along at an aircooled 4.8GHz on almost any motherboard. The Core i5-2405S has the low energy bit handled like a champ, but it barely overclocks and at stock is pretty damn slow. So you save almost nothing by buying a much slower CPU for the same amount of money.
All in all about the only people who could possibly be interested in the Core i5-2405S are those who want a low-power CPU for an HTPC or plan on doing nothing more stressful than browsing the internet. If you game, the 2500K is the same money and an infinitely better buy. If you're in business then there are a plethora of low-power CPUs around that will run Word and the like for a lot less money than this.
This is exactly the type of CPU that will turn up in your local PC World. Sure 2.5 GHz of Quad Core energy-efficient power sounds great when told to someone who thinks PCs still have floppy drives. For everybody else there are other options that are better in any department you care to measure.