ASUS Maximus II Formula P45 Motherboard

Conclusion

Conclusion
 
I found it very hard not to adore this motherboard to be quite honest. Visually, the board is stunning with new look gun metal grey heat sinks splashed with blood red 'shields', which is a much more appealing sight than copper coloured aluminium heat sinks of old. The Maximus' layout is nigh on perfect, with all the connections in the right places making for clutter free cabling. The now standard on board power and reset switches are, as always, a godsend for anyone building a rig outside of a case for benchmarking and testing. Perhaps my only gripe with the aesthetics of the board is that the two perpendicular SATA slots are not very secure because the SATA cables don't 'latch' into the slots. Hence, confidence of a good fit is lost, but that is a minor blemish on what is possibly the best designed motherboard to come out of the Asus arena to date.
 
The performance of the board is, as expected, on par with other P45 motherboards we have tested, if perhaps a little higher performing in the 3D gaming area. There is a wealth of overclocking options in the BIOS that will satisfy even the most ardent of enthusiasts and with handy little explanations of what most of the options do, novice clockers shouldn't find it to difficult to experiment. As there are also dual BIOS chips, any overzealous clocking shouldn't result in a non-bootable scenario and I can testify that I didn't once have to reset the BIOS, with the board auto recovering from my many over ambitious overclocking attempts.
 
There are, however, a few areas in which the Maximus II may not be the best idea. Firstly, the price. Weighing in at around £180, this is a very expensive motherboard for what is touted as a mid-range chipset. At a similar price point, an X48 based motherboard could be had, which may hurt sales of the Maximus II. While I haven't noticed any noticeable slowdown between the P45 and X48, if you intend on going multi-GPU at the same price point, it makes sense to go for a board with the higher numbers, in this case, double the amount of PCIe lanes. It may not effect the current crop of graphics cards, but in the future it might, although to what extent no one can tell. There is also the P5Q range of motherboards to contend with, also from Asus which, with regard to the P5Q Deluxe, perform at least on a par with the Maximus II, leaving you to pay an extra £60 for the luxuries the Maximus II has to offer and luxuries it most certainly has - but £60 worth?
 
Secondly, with Nehelem on the horizon forcing a new chipset, DDR3 and new CPU socket, plumping for a high-end LGA775 based motherboard this late in the game may seem a little brash if you intend to take advantage of Intel's next generation of CPU's. This, of course, is not a fault of the Maximus II. Rather, it is a case of it being a victim of evolution, but it is something I'm sure is on the mind of most potential buyers at the moment. Playing the waiting game in the hardware market has always been tricky due to the rapid advances in technology, and as such many people buy 'for the now' and if that is indeed your stance and you are looking for a new motherboard, then I can find no reason, other than the above, not to buy a Maximus II Formula, which I would happily recommend as 'King of P45'.
 
 
The Good
- Multitude of BIOS options
- Excellent BIOS recovery
- Visually stunning
- X-FI riser card
- 16 phase power design
- Screw down heatsinks
- Energy saving
- LCD Poster options
- Support for 16GB of DDR2
 
The Mediocre
- The Q-plate. I would like to have seen an EL version at this price point.
- Budget SATA cables
- Ribbon cables. Rounded cables should be statutory by now.
- SATA port - no locking mechanism
- X-FI instead of Xonar
 
The Poor
- The price. It will be hard to justify £180 for this instead of an X48 variant.
 
 
Overclock3D Best In Class Award
 
 
Many thanks to ASUS for providing us with the Maximus II Formula for this review.
 
Discuss in our forums
«Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Next»

Most Recent Comments

10-07-2008, 08:45:38

JN
"With more features than ever before, very cool looking heatsinks and a shiny new chipset. Does the Maximus II have what it takes to be crowned P45 King?" - By Webbo

http://www.overclock3d.net/gfx/artic...234845465s.jpg



ASUS Maximus II Formula P45 Motherboard

10-07-2008, 09:01:45

Bungral
Tis very very nice indeed. I really like the look of it.

That said.. With the new Rampage looking just as good, If I had the wedge and was after a new mobo, I'd plump for the Rampage.

10-07-2008, 09:57:02

Mr. Smith
Rich, your OC tests - is the 3.9 jiggahurtz stable or just a screenie? Also, how does that compare to other mobos you've had the chip on?

I think that is relevant...

Ta

10-07-2008, 10:15:55

w3bbo
Prime95 was run for overnight (8 hours) aswell as a 1hr hour OCCT run - not exactly proof of 24/7 stability but it's good enough imo. This is compared against similar results with the MSI and P5Q deluxe. I rated the Maximus higher as, along with the ridiculous amount of BIOS tweaks available with more time and a more mature BIOS it is my belief the Maximus can at least equal the P5Q, not only that but gaming wise the maximus is already ahead of the P5Q albeit not by much.

Also overclocking on air, as I'm sure you are aware, can be heavily influenced by ambient air temps which due to the recent hot weather is limiting the possibilities. Using phase change is not realy an option as it isn't indicative of the 'average' user and wouldn't give a fair representation of the possibilities of the motherboard.

Because the P45 uses PCIE 2.0 which is double the bandwidth of PCIe 1.1 the need for 16 lanes is debatable so going for an X48 (which appears not to clock as good as P45) is not a decision that should be taken lightly. I guess it comes down to if you want every last ounce of CPU or GPU power - CPU = P45, GPU=X48 imo.

10-07-2008, 11:20:50

Luigi
Wow, Nice review

One thing that was in the press release, but I didnt see demonstrated, was the removable part of heatpipe cooling on the NB?

Is this possible?

10-07-2008, 11:22:20

WC Annihilus
Edit: think I read that wrong

10-07-2008, 11:26:52

Luigi
Yeah, apparently just the NB part can be taking off for water cooling, so you dont have to do the whole board?

10-07-2008, 11:30:17

WC Annihilus
Looking at the removed assembly pic, I don't really see how that would work, but I suppose I should let webbo answer this one

10-07-2008, 11:38:19

w3bbo
Yes it is possible - I'll upload a pic of that for you but I didn't include it in the review due to space constraints and the fact I can't understand why anyone would want to as if you are going to apply an aftermarket solution, the whole heatpipe would be best to be removed. I thought it better to include the whole heatpipe removal than just the top of the NB.

Just for you :

http://www.overclock3d.net/gfx/artic...163754119l.jpg

As you can see, if you used an aftermarket solution you would in effect be creating a sandwhich effect and the cooling would be hampered by having to battle with two lots of TIM. Hence, best to remove the whole lot if that is your aim.

10-07-2008, 12:55:17

Pjalchemist
Loving my bord. Right out the box been able to hit 600FSB after latest BIOS update. It is eye catching. I can see there point in regards to the NB WC option, not much room to play though. Glad they have ditched push pins and the so called TIM. Think they lost too many bords that way! Luck has it i have an X38 IHS so when it come to going DICE on the NB i'll lid it. Nice review and nice ES bord!

10-07-2008, 13:00:44

w3bbo
Cheers Pete

31-08-2008, 07:52:17

ogmw
Hello im new to these forums and to overclocking so hello...

I have the Same MB and a Q6600 CPU and OCZ DDR2 platinum 800 RAM...

Just wanting to know the settings for the 3.6ghz OC and also is it stable?

Thanks
Reply
x

Register for the OC3D Newsletter

Subscribing to the OC3D newsletter will keep you up-to-date on the latest technology reviews, competitions and goings-on at Overclock3D. We won't share your email address with ANYONE, and we will only email you with updates on site news, reviews, and competitions and you can unsubscribe easily at any time.

Simply enter your name and email address into the box below and be sure to click on the links in the confirmation emails that will arrive in your e-mail shortly after to complete the registration.

If you run into any problems, just drop us a message on the forums.