BitFenix Prodigy M Review

Conclusion

BitFenix Prodigy M Review

Conclusion

This isn't going to be one of our massively long conclusions.  The exterior of the Prodigy has had plenty of exposure since the release of the original Mini-ITX version all those moons ago, and it's fair to say we love it here at OC3D.  It's a great looking case that has gone from strength to strength with BitFenix releasing additional colours to refresh the line as well as solid front panels and windowed side panels to add that little bit more variety. 

The release of the Prodigy M has seen BitFenix alter the internals of the chassis in order to accommodate the Micro-ATX motherboard.  Perhaps this was in response to the large numbers in the modding community who were converting the original to M-ATX, or perhaps it had always been a part of the grand plan for the chassis, whatever the impetus, here it is.  The new internals are identical to those of the recently reviewed Phenom M, and as with the Phenom M the internals of the Prodigy M bring both advantages and disadvantages over the original Mini-ITX format.  The main drawback of having more space given over to the Motherboard is the loss of the prodigious radiator capacity that the Mini-ITX version has.  Now that's not to say you're not going to be able to get wet with the M because you are, it's still able to house a 35mm thick rad in the roof which means pretty much all of the current crop of 240mm based AIOs such as the H100i and Seidon 240 will fit just fine.  There is a trade-off here though which is that although the larger motherboard brings with it additional PCI slots to which the M caters with its 5 expansion bays, you are going to have to surrender some of these if you want a rad in the roof, which basically means you're down to a single GPU.  If you absolutely have to go multi GPU and still want to get wet then all is not lost as the rear of the M is able to accept a 140 or 120 fan, which in turn means that such units as the Kraken X40 and the H90 and H80i are viable options.  If the thought of adding water to the inside of your PC case still fills you with dread you'll be delighted to know that the Prodigy M can accept CPU coolers up to 160mm and even 195mm if you're happy to loose a few HDDs.  The Prodigy is also able to accept long GPUs, anything up to 320mm in fact but you are going to have to think about how you route the wiring out  of the top of the PSU to avoid conflicts. 

So what are the advantages of the M-ATX format of the Prodigy case?  Well it pretty much boils down to the price and additional features often offered by the M-ATX format.  Pound for pound M-ATX motherboards do tend to be cheaper than comparable Mini-ITX boards.  Let's take as an example the latest crop of Asus Maximus boards, the Mini-ITX Maximus VI Impact with its single PCI slot and only 2 RAM slots will set you back about £190, whereas the Micro-ATX Maximus VI Gene with 4 RAM slots and dual GPU capabilities will only cost you in the region of £160, representing a £30 saving, and that's before we're even looked at SATA ports and chipset cooling.  Yes we know there are some very cheap Mini-ITX boards out there, but then again there are also some very good value M-ATX boards if overclocking’s not your thing and you want to go low power.

Whether you opt for the original Mini-ITX version or the new Micro-ATX Prodigy M the fact is that you now have a choice, and with the M version priced a £75 and so costing just a fiver more than the original Mini-ITX both cases still represent excellent value for money.  Which one you go for will depend largely on what your needs are, either way you won't be disappointed.
 

         

Thanks to BitFenix for sending in the Prodigy-M for review, you can discuss your thoughts in the OC3D Forums. 

«Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Next»

Most Recent Comments

21-10-2013, 05:42:59

tinytomlogan
http://www.overclock3d.net/gfx/artic...075804270l.jpg

"It's a Prodigy Jim, but not as we know it". Lets see what the familiar Prodigy looks like with an M-ATX motherboard squeezes inside.

Continue Reading

21-10-2013, 06:07:13

SieB
It's a shame that all they did was take the itx version and copy what the modders have been doing.

The case is a bit cramped for M-ATX, with the itx version you have plenty of room for decent water cooling and good airflow. You were also not restricted on the length of the GPU either.

I think Bitfenix could of put more effort in and made the case slightly bigger for the M-ATX version. Either that or just stick to the itx design but make the case wider so you can fit a M-ATX board in the way you fitted the itx one in the original Prodigy.

It's not a bad case and does the job, but I can't help thinking it could have been much better.

21-10-2013, 06:11:05

Feronix
Exactly. There's too much compromise for my liking.

Surprised it got a Gold Award if I'm honest, but it was still a good read

21-10-2013, 07:56:39

barnsley
This just makes me want to work on a M-ATX machine for myself even more now. The others are right though, there does seem to be too much of a compromise, I'd rather go for the Bitfenix phenom .

21-10-2013, 08:01:57

tinytomlogan
Quote:
Originally Posted by barnsley View Post
This just makes me want to work on a M-ATX machine for myself even more now. The others are right though, there does seem to be too much of a compromise, I'd rather go for the Bitfenix phenom .
Only the outside is different.

21-10-2013, 08:16:27

Feronix
Quote:
Originally Posted by tinytomlogan View Post
Only the outside is different.
Just a question btw, I've noticed that the Phenom (mITX) has the exact same inside, including the 5.25" bay... Except the front panel is completely clean?

http://vorming.minatica.be/ict2013/B...henomMini1.jpg

Think I'm going for an mITX Phenom in white. Maybe slap a white Prodigy windowed panel on there, cause there's no windowed Phenom available...

21-10-2013, 08:53:03

barnsley
Quote:
Originally Posted by tinytomlogan View Post
Only the outside is different.

Welp, no Phenom for me, I thought they were different but must've got mixed up with something else.

21-10-2013, 08:55:44

Feronix
Quote:
Originally Posted by barnsley View Post
Welp, no Phenom for me, I thought they were different but must've got mixed up with something else.
There are:

-mITX Prodigy
-mATX Prodigy
-mITX Phenom
-mATX Phenom

Both ITX cases are the same on the inside, as well as both mATX cases. I personally like the look of the Phenom more, but I'm not a fan of the mATX version of either.

21-10-2013, 09:00:24

barnsley
Quote:
Originally Posted by Feronix View Post

Both ITX cases are the same on the inside, as well as both mATX cases. I personally like the look of the Phenom more, but I'm not a fan of the mATX version of either.
Ah right, thanks for clearing it up . Yeah, I do think the Phenom looks fantastic as well however I am leaning towards The Elite 130 in terms of ITX as I do love a LED front fan/black case combo for some reason

21-10-2013, 09:03:38

Feronix
Quote:
Originally Posted by barnsley View Post
Ah right, thanks for clearing it up . Yeah, I do think the Phenom looks fantastic as well however I am leaning towards The Elite 130 in terms of ITX as I do love a LED front fan/black case combo for some reason
Haha, fair enough. I'm past the point where I liked LED fans

The Elite 130 is a good case though, very compact and can still fit some high-end gear. Cheap as well! I'm personally going with the Bitfenix case cause I think it looks better and it supports watercooling.

Either would make a nice Lanbox though!

21-10-2013, 09:08:59

barnsley
Quote:
Originally Posted by Feronix View Post
Haha, fair enough. I'm past the point where I liked LED fans

Either would make a nice Lanbox though!
Yeah, I used to think I was past LED fans etc, but it has grown on me again D:. I am planning to make a lanbox , it'll either have an i5 or one of the budget X4 750k AMD cpus with my current 7870, it'll depend how much I spend on upgrades on my main pc...

21-10-2013, 11:11:57

Rastalovich
They've listened to comments, this case is something I/we will be looking into alot.

30-10-2013, 16:43:26

Timo
Yeah, lovely case. I've thought about it and would love a -Larger version- of this case. Say 230mm wide, 400mm high: 2 x140mm intakes at the front, 140 exhaust and room for a 280 rad on the top. i.e. an m/atx with room to breath.

16-03-2014, 07:07:13

Lucasino8
Basically what I want to know before buying this case, can you just put it upside down (and change the logo (maybe switch the sidepanels))? If so wouldn't it cause any problems? And why didn't BitFenix do it themselves, I mean are they braindead?

Greetz.

16-03-2014, 07:14:41

tinytomlogan
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lucasino8 View Post
Basically what I want to know before buying this case, can you just put it upside down (and change the logo (maybe switch the sidepanels))? If so wouldn't it cause any problems? And why didn't BitFenix do it themselves, I mean are they braindead?

Greetz.
panels could be switched but as for turning the front upside down you would also neeed to do the roof too.... Its not something I think we could answer now without going to rip the case apart again just to answer this. Youd be better hoping one of the members has one tbh.

16-03-2014, 07:41:35

Feronix
Quote:
Originally Posted by tinytomlogan View Post
panels could be switched but as for turning the front upside down you would also neeed to do the roof too.... Its not something I think we could answer now without going to rip the case apart again just to answer this. Youd be better hoping one of the members has one tbh.
Actually... Installing 2x120mm fans as intakes in the bottom (former roof) might improve the (GPU) temps a bit, which I found seriously lacking in the mATX versions of the Bitfenix cases.

You might want to make a custom panel for the new top (former bottom) though, it won't look that pretty leaving it like it is.

http://i1296.photobucket.com/albums/...ps59a1040c.png

@Lucas: If you want to dicuss this further I suggest you make your own thread in the Cases & Power section instead of using the review thread
http://forum.overclock3d.net/forumdisplay.php?f=26
Reply
x

Register for the OC3D Newsletter

Subscribing to the OC3D newsletter will keep you up-to-date on the latest technology reviews, competitions and goings-on at Overclock3D. We won't share your email address with ANYONE, and we will only email you with updates on site news, reviews, and competitions and you can unsubscribe easily at any time.

Simply enter your name and email address into the box below and be sure to click on the links in the confirmation emails that will arrive in your e-mail shortly after to complete the registration.

If you run into any problems, just drop us a message on the forums.