Razer Barracuda HP-1 Gaming Headphones

Testing Method & Results

Testing Method

To fully put the Barracuda's through their paces, I tested them out on three soundcards and a range of games and music. The soundcards used were the Creative Soundblaster Audigy 2 ZS Gamer, the Creative X-Fi XtremeGamer and the Abit AB9 Pro On-Board soundcard. All of these soundcards have 5.1 capabilities and each were using the latest drivers in Windows Vista.

My software tests included the following:

- Counter-Strike: Source
- Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell Double Agent
- CD played with Windows Media Player 11
- DVD played with Windows Media Player 11
- Teamspeak RC2 and Ventrilo (gaming communications)

My main focus would be with the gaming performance of these headphones as this is what they have been designed for. I chose Counterstrike: Source and Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell for a number of differenct reasons. Firstly, Counter-Strike: Source requires pinpoint accuracy in which to seek out your opponents footsteps. Therefore I would be looking for exceptional directional clarity, impressive depth and range combined with a solid balance between bass and treble (bass for the firing guns and treble for the tinkle of shells dropping to the floor). With Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell, I would be looking for clarity and depth in not only the sound effects but the audio performance from characters walking and talking combined with the overall ambiance created.

For the music testing, I focussed on around 10 songs, all from different genres from rock, to classical, to R&B. This allowed me to listen for the clarity and depth in the range compared to my current Sennheiser headphones along with picking up any distortions in the sound quality. I also tested the Barracuda's with a scene from the film "Blade" which I've always found great for testing surround sound.

Finally the microphones performance was tested in both teamspeak and ventrilo for in-game communications in order to establish the clarity and performance of this rather small microphone.


Gaming Results

The first game to test the Barracuda's was Counter-Strike: Source and my impressions were somewhat mixed. The directional sounds were impressive and there was a new level of depth that my current headphones could not match. Picking out footsteps on walkways above me become a lot more easier as not only did the surround sound pinpoint the area in which the footsteps originated, but also, the distance and angle away from my position. Most impressive! However the reasons for my mixed feelings came down to the apparent lack of bass. Compared to normal stereo headphones, the bass felt quite empty leaving quite a "tinny" feel to the whole experience. This however did improve when using the headphones with the Creative X-Fi XtremeGamer soundcard, so this made me think about what the Barracuda's would be like when using Razers own soundcard, the AC-1.

Counter-Strike:Source

However I must point out at this stage that it would be unfair to compare a 5.1 headset to a stereo headset. Having used Speedlink Medusa headphones in the past which are also 5.1, I can confirm that the Barracuda's were superior!

Next was Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell Double Agent. This did sound better than Counter-Strike: Source with great spacial depth and clarity. Footsteps, ambient sounds, speech and gunfire all felt very realistic and immersive. Again the bass was not as strong as my normal stereo headphones, but the 5.1 raised the gaming experience leaving me feeling pleasently pleased with the Barracuda's.

Splinter Cell

Overall, the Barracuda's delivered good surround-sound although bass was lacking somewhat. No matter what I did in tweaking the various balance levels, I couldn't get the thumping bass that I wanted. This left me feeling slightly frustrated as the surround sound did work well to a certain extent but I could just not get that "perfect" feeling when in game. Perhaps the Razer AC-1 sound card will implement some HRTF functions, audio delays or sound coloring to make sounds from the rear drivers sound like they're behind you and the front drivers like they're in front of you, as I struggled to get a perfect balance. However I appreciate that these are headphones which cannot replicate the effect a 5.1 speaker system would offer as the speakers are so close to your ears.


Music Results

Using Media Player 11 along with CD's (as I did not want to test MP3's due to differing bitrates) I proceeded to test out a wide variety of music. Now this did sound good! I'm assuming due to the size of the ear cups, the sound did seem to spread out more and the treble clarity was very impressive. Bass was improved a great deal over the gaming experience, although still not strong enough for my liking. However, in testing a wide variety of music, the Barracuda's really were "on song" (excuse the pun!). There was no apparent distortion even when they were turned up to the highest volume and in tweaking the volume balance between speakers, you could clearly hear the depth and position change of the sound - it was much more apparent than in games.


DVD Results

My DVD choice for testing surround sound is always Blade! There is a scene where Wesley Snipes throws a boomarang type blade around a room, which does a full circle. This is always a very good test when using surround sound as you can hear the blade circle right around your head. So how did the Barracuda's do? Well very well indeed, especially for a set of headphones. The experience was extremely immersive and the sound did travel all around the room, or so it seemed, so very impressive! Also the clarity of the speech was excelent along with punchy bass. For a gaming headset, I found it's performance most impressive.


Microphone Results

When purchasing a headset for gaming, it is imperative that a microphone is included for in game communications. Thankfully Razer has provided just the thing! As previously mentioned, the microphone itself is rather small and detachable (not good if you have a habit of losing things). With this in mind, I'm interested to see how it performs compared to other microphones (namely my Sennheisers). Well it's on par with the Sennheisers without a question, which for a small microphone is impressive.

When using Ventrillo or Teamspeak2, speech was clear and easy to understand which is all I require from my microphone. I did however find the clarity was at it's best when using the Creative X-Fi XtremeGamer soundcard and can only attribute this to the technology used in this card. Overall I had no gripes with the microphone performance and was more than happy with it for gaming use.
«Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next»

Most Recent Comments

21-06-2007, 15:21:12

JN
"Today we put Razer's Barracuda HP-1 headphones in the hands of our very own professional gamer - Chris "Ins" Buer. Read on to find out if they improved his game or just left him open to attacks from the rear!"

http://www.overclock3d.net/gfx/artic...192104169s.jpg

Linkage

21-06-2007, 15:37:12

Ham
Oww @ the price...

If they were cheaper perhaps.

Good job Insy

21-06-2007, 16:03:47

FarFarAway
Agreed if they were cheaper I would plump for a pair

21-06-2007, 17:08:52

PinGu^
Ive used these before, Really impressed with them. Look flimsy.. but are perfect for lans

My speedlink medusa does me fine tho

21-06-2007, 17:13:58

mrapoc
Who had them dan?

21-06-2007, 17:59:29

PinGu^
The ginger troll (deathwishes brother)

21-06-2007, 18:09:52

mrapoc
ahhh lol

21-06-2007, 23:20:16

PV5150
I have a pair and they are an awesome addition, although they are extremely dear.

22-06-2007, 06:05:52

prosser13
Look nice

I don't see how he hasn't heard of Rocketboy though, seeing as theres an Abit Rocketboy motherboard

22-06-2007, 06:06:10

!TIMMY!
good review ins, they do look good, and the xtreme gamer can give them that extra bass; but the price U can get medusa's for 35 these days.

23-06-2007, 15:38:54

Thanh55
Look at the price, dear me. I need one for my i31 coming up but too expensive. Any similar but do not get to high price. I think 50 max.

24-06-2007, 09:38:21

PinGu^
Quote:
Originally Posted by name='Thanh55'
Look at the price, dear me. I need one for my i31 coming up but too expensive. Any similar but do not get to high price. I think 50 max.
Get a speedlink Medusa. I know alot of people in this forum has one. Very good for gaming, music + dvds

24-06-2007, 09:39:36

Ham
Or the Zalman Theater 6. Theyre good.

25-06-2007, 03:50:07

old.gregg
My son's stopped using his Barracudas 'cos too many people were saying that they couldn't hear him very well - the mic does seem to be positioned too far away from your mouth.

Personally, using them for Skype, I got very good results.

For the price, the build quality is shockingly poor.

And a bit tight for my fat head.

He bought some Steelsound phones to replace them. They don't impress me too much - you can hear everything going on around you, no audio encapsulation at all.

25-06-2007, 11:49:03

[Ins]
I still maintain that for competitive gaming and overall clarity in sound, you can't beat a decent pair of Sennheisers!

The PC166's that I purchased recently are extremely good indeed!

25-06-2007, 13:21:13

AmBush
I Got Sennheiser PC150 & PC160 i've been happy with Both apart from the inline On/Off switch which on my PC150 i have had to tape in the on position,

The PC 160 is going now The Barracuda inline switch looks very robust.

16-02-2010, 02:39:40

stupidregistration
Very poor quality construction.

Wiring is subject to faults due to very bad soldering.

Padding degrades and falls apart in first week of use.

16-02-2010, 04:50:25

Youngie1337
Who is this professional gamer?.

Anything from Razer is a God send.

18-01-2013, 23:53:37

Stoogie
i baught these on the first day they came out, with the soundcard, i used them for about 30 mins, the screw snapped in half out of 1 of the cup hinges and the entire cup fell off, threw it in the bin directly afterwards cause it was unusable
Reply
x

Register for the OC3D Newsletter

Subscribing to the OC3D newsletter will keep you up-to-date on the latest technology reviews, competitions and goings-on at Overclock3D. We won't share your email address with ANYONE, and we will only email you with updates on site news, reviews, and competitions and you can unsubscribe easily at any time.

Simply enter your name and email address into the box below and be sure to click on the links in the confirmation emails that will arrive in your e-mail shortly after to complete the registration.

If you run into any problems, just drop us a message on the forums.